Dogs, Franks, Hots:

  • Nathan’s Hot Dog : It’s our only all-beef hot dog, made with the classic Coney Island style recipe. It’s a juicy dog with a hint of garlic.  Skinless (no casing) …………………$2.49

  • “Imported” from Milwaukee:

    • Milwaukee’s Frankfurter by Usinger’s:  Made with premium beef and pork with the biggest, boldest flavor of all our offerings. The Frankfurt-style that brought hot dogs to America! Skinless (green arrow pick)…$2.99
    • Usinger’s Bochwurst: The most unique and distinctive wurst, like no other. Made with the finest pork and veal, blended with eggs, onion and parsley. Don’t top it till you taste it. Natural casing. (yellow arrow pick)……$2.99
    • Usinger’s Milwaukee Wiener:  Made with premium beef and pork but with the subtle seasoning preferred in Austria. A superb product that is wildly popular with our customers. Natural casing. (pink arrow pick)…..  $3.19

    • “Imported” from Rochester:

      • Zwiegle’s Texas Red Hot:  Zwiegles has ruled the hot dog world in Rochester since 1880! See why in this premium beef and pork masterpiece in a snappy natural casing.  They are NOT SPICY but they sure are special.  33% larger than a regular hot dog too! (red sword pick)  .. $3.39
      • Zwiegle’s White Hot: Made of veal and pork, these “hots” bring a truly different taste to the world of hot dogs.  Suble and mild, they are a nice “change of pace” dog.  NOT spicy, they just call them “hots” in Rochester. NO ADDED NITRATES. Also 33% larger than a regular dog (white arrow pick).. $3.39


        • Jolly Roger Special:

        Hot Dog Sampler of all six dogs above $17.39 (Save $1.05!)

        • Usinger’s Milwaukee Knackwurst:  This is simply the very best quality knackwurst you will ever sample.  Together with the brat they are like “Starsky and Hutch” starring on our incomparable “Wurst Plate”.  Made with beef, pork and garlic and a smoke finish. 4.5 per lb. Here as a solo act on a bun ….. $4.19
        • Usinger’s Course Ground Bratwurst:  Made by Usinger’s in Milwaukee since 1880.  It’s a classic brat, made of only the finest veal and pork with a savory herb recipe….. $4.19
      • Italian Sausage (Hot or Sweet):  Homemade by Andy & Sons Deli on Delaware Avenue, it’s the finest, leanest sausage of its kind anywhere. Served with grilled onions and peppers on a Mastroani Bros. Italian Torpedo Roll…… $6.99
      • Special PLG “WURST PLATE”:  Two Usinger’s Wursts from Milwaukee (A Knackwurst AND a Bratwurst) served on a bed of sauerkraut with potato pancakes. Simply the best wurst plate you will find anywhere…… $9.39

      • Burgers:

        • Big Beef Burger (1/3 lb. 100% Pure Angus Beef) $5.99
        • Bigger Bison Burger (6 oz.)(white sword pick)…..  $7.99
        • Local Organic Grass-Fed Pure Beef Burger (1/3 lb. Sweet Tree Farm, Carlisle)(Yellow sword pick)… $7.99
        • Jr. Pirate Burger (1/6 lb.)…….$3.39
          • Buccaneer Double Burger (with chese and lettuce & tomato or slaw) $6.69

        Other Great Foods:

        • Grilled Chicken Cutlet $5.19
        • Gardenburger (Vegetarian) $5.19
        • Chicken Tenders(3 large)(includes 1 dipping sauce)……$4.69
        • Homemade Meat Chili (12 oz.)………..$5.29

        Fish Fry:

        • Sea Dog (Cod)Fish Fry Sandwich $5.89
        • Clam Roll …….  $4.69
        • Butterfly Shrimp Plate (w/Fries & Cole Slaw)  $9.39
        • Combo Plate: butterfly shrimp, clam strips
        • and a small fish fry (w/Fries & Cole Slaw)   $14.69

All sandwiches include the following toppings at no additional cost:

Ketchup, Sweet relish, Mayonnaise, Mustard (Yellow, deli or spicy brown), Raw onions, Lettuce, Tomato, Jalapeno peppers, Hot sauce, Horseradish, or Pickle.


Super-Buccaneer Toppings:

  • Meat Chili Sauce (Homemade) $0.90
  • Cheese Sauce (Cheddar) $0.45
  • Sauteed Onions $0.40
  • Sauteed Mushrooms $1.00

Other Extras:

  • Sliced Cheese(American, Swiss, Cheddar) $0.70
  • Gorgonzola crumbles…. $1.20
  • Sauerkraut…. $0.40
  • Bacon on Hot Dog or Wurst… $0.70
  • Bacon on any other sandwich $1.40


Wurst Plate (knackwurst and bratwurst) both from Milwaukee, served with sauerkraut and potato pancakes and applesauce…..The Very Best Wurst in the Region!!!    $9.39




  • Awesome French Fries …..Small $1.89  Regular $2.79
  • Cheese Fries (Awesome & Cheese) …Small $2.49  Regular $3.69
  • Chili Cheese Fries (Awesome with Awesome & Cheese)…Small $3.29  Reg.  $4.59
  • Onion Rings (Beer Battered) (one size only) $3.39
  • Cole Slaw ……Small $ 1.29  Regular $2.49
  • Potato Salad or Macaroni Salad (one size only). $2.09

Kid’s Menu (12 & Under)

  1. Jr. Pirate Burger…$3.39  Meal**…………..$6.00

  2. Jr. Sea Dog…………$3.45  Meal**…………..$6.00

3.  Nathans Hot Dog Meal**………$5.10

4.  Scallywag Meal**(tenders)….$5.45

**Kid’s Meals include a small french fry order and a soda, juice or water.


  • Can of Soda (Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Orange, Sprite, Grape, Ginger Ale, Root Beer or Diet Root Beer) $1.62
  • Bottled Spring Water $1.62
  • Iced Tea (Arizona Lemon or Green) $1.71
  • Unsweetened Iced Tea (Pure Leaf) $2.00
  • Lemonade (Minute Maid) $1.62
  • Juice Boxes (100% juice) $1.35


  • Old Fashioned, Hand Made Milkshakes (Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, Coffee, Mocha or “Shake O’ The Week” Special) The Best! $3.70
  • Root Beer, Pepsi or Orange Float              $3.70


Ice Cream:



  • Ice Cream: Vanilla, Chocolate, Twist (Cone or Cup)
  • Regular $2.59
  • Large $3.19
  • Kiddie $1.76
  • Sprinkles $ .37

  • Milkshakes (Chocolate, Vanilla, Coffee, Strawberry, Mocha, or “Shake O’ The Week”) $3.70
  • Root Beer, Pepsi or Orange Float $3.70


  • Chocolate or Hot Fudge)
  • Regular $4.19
  • Large $5.19

Special Sandwiches:

  • We currently offer 16 “EveryDay” Special Hot Dogs and Burgers. Check our Facebook page to learn of our “Weekly Specials” which are offered for only one week at a time, rotated throughout the season.